When to Replace Siding vs. Painting It in Carmel, IN

Have you noticed that your home’s siding is starting to look run down? When your siding isn’t necessarily damaged but looks severely faded, you have two primary options for dealing with it: replace it or paint it. So, how do you decide when it’s time to replace your siding vs. painting it? We’re here to help!

Below, you’ll learn more about the most important factors to consider and the pros and cons of each option to help you make your decision. If you have any questions for our siding experts in the meantime, we hope you’ll reach out to us by calling 317-884-3140 or contacting us online. 

When to Replace Siding vs. Painting It: The Most Important Things to Consider

Before you decide whether to replace or paint your siding, take a quick look at your home’s exterior and think about the following considerations: 

• The age of your siding: If your siding is close to or more than 20 years old, it is probably starting to reach the end of its lifespan. In that case, it likely makes more sense to replace it now, rather than paint it now and replace it in another year or so. 
• The condition of your siding: When you visually inspect your siding, keep an eye out for serious signs of damage like cracks, bulges, or holes. These serious types of issues can’t be fixed with paint, so you’re better off replacing your siding instead. 
• Your budget: Finally, think about how much you’re able to spend. Painting your siding is a cost-effective option, but often not a permanent solution, so you may end up having to pay for a replacement soon after painting, costing you more in the long run. 

Pros and Cons of Replacing Your Siding

Before you make your decision about which path to take, consider the advantages and disadvantages of replacing your siding.

Pro: Peace of Mind

If you decide to replace your siding with a high-quality and durable material like James Hardie siding, you won’t have to worry about issues with your exterior for the next several decades. 

Pro: Boost Your Curb Appeal

Adding new siding to your home can instantly improve your curb appeal, making it a great investment in your property. 

Pro: Get More for Your Money

Replacing your siding is about more than just making your exterior look better. For example, new siding often provides extra insulation, which can make your home more energy efficient.

Pro: Prevent Future Issues

When you hire our expert siding installers, we’ll check for signs of damage underneath your siding, making any necessary repairs to keep your home protected. 

Con: Costs More

The only true con to replacing your siding is that it costs more money upfront. However, we proudly offer financing and special offers to help make your siding replacement more affordable. 

Pros and Cons of Painting Your Siding

Is painting your siding a better option? Consider the pros and cons of this choice for your home. 

Pro: Color Options

Do you want your siding to be a unique color? You may be able to find more color options if you choose painting instead of replacing your siding. 

Pro: Lower Upfront Cost

If money is tight, painting your siding is a more cost-effective option, at least for the immediate future. 

Con: Precision Is Key

If you decide to paint your siding, you can’t pick just any old paint for the job. You’ll need a specific exterior paint that can withstand the elements. Beyond that, you have to make sure you paint your siding correctly, or it will start to chip, fade, or flake away.

Con: May Void Your Warranty

Depending on the type of siding currently on your home, painting it may void your existing warranty. In that case, you’d be responsible if future issues develop. 

Con: Short-Term Solution

Painting your siding can give it an instant refresh, but keep in mind that it’s only a short-term fix. Depending on the age of your siding you’ll either need to repaint it again in a few years or replace it if issues start to develop. 

Are You Ready to Replace Your Siding? 

After reading this guide, you can see that when it comes to time to decide whether to replace your siding vs. painting it, a replacement has more advantages. If you’ve decided to move forward with a full siding replacement in Carmel, IN, you can trust UHQ Construction to do the job quickly, efficiently, and for the right price. To request a free estimate, please call 317-884-3140 or contact us online.